
Kirkland Quality: What Costco Gets Right — and What Direct Care Can Learn
Kirkland isn’t “cheap.” It’s intentionally excellent. Costco is willing to put its name behind fewer products, demand higher quality, accept lower margins, and walk away from suppliers who won’t meet standards. The result? A brand customers trust almost automatically.
That philosophy maps surprisingly well to :contentReference[oaicite:2]{index=2}.
1. Fewer Options, Higher Confidence
Kirkland doesn’t offer twelve versions of olive oil. It offers one — because Costco already did the hard work. Customers don’t want infinite choice; they want confidence.
Direct care works the same way. Instead of endless networks, tiers, authorizations, and fine print, patients get a simple promise: this is your doctor, this is what it costs, this is how it works. Less cognitive load. More trust.
2. Radical Quality Control
Kirkland products are often manufactured by top-tier brands — just held to stricter specs and sold without the marketing markup. Costco’s reputation is on the line, so quality is non-negotiable.
In direct care, quality isn’t outsourced to billing rules or insurance incentives. Time, access, continuity, and clinical judgment are the product. When physicians answer directly to patients instead of payers, quality improves because accountability is immediate and personal.
3. Honest Pricing, Not Psychological Games
Costco’s margins are famously thin. They don’t rely on coupons, gotchas, or “limited-time” tricks. Customers know they’re getting a fair deal — every time.
Direct care mirrors this with transparent pricing, no surprise bills, and no post-visit financial anxiety. Patients don’t wonder what something might cost weeks later. They know upfront.
The Real Lesson: Earned Trust Scales
Kirkland didn’t grow by promising everything to everyone. It grew by being dependable, boring in the best way, and relentlessly focused on value.
Direct care doesn’t need to out-market the healthcare system. It just needs to out-behave it.
Trust, once earned, does the rest.

Part 3: The Aldi Cult — Turning Value Into Community (Without Getting Weird)
There are Facebook groups. Subreddits. Inside jokes. People post their “finds” like they’re sharing treasure from a secret society. They wear Aldi shirts. They talk about “the hunt.”
This is the part most industries miss: value gets people in the door, but identity keeps them coming back.
And DPC can learn from that—because direct care, at its best, naturally creates the kind of loyalty that insurance-based systems struggle to earn.
People don’t share “health care.” They share wins.
Nobody posts online: “Had a normal primary care visit today. Very standard.”
But they will share:
- “My doctor texted me back in 10 minutes.”
- “I got a same-day visit.”
- “My labs were $18 instead of $180.”
- “They actually listened.”
- “No surprise bill.”
Those are “Aldi finds”—the moments that feel like cheating the system in a fair way.
Direct care should intentionally collect and amplify these stories (with patient permission), because they translate the abstract benefits into something tangible.
The “middle aisle” idea for DPC
Aldi has its core goods, but it also has a rotating middle aisle of unexpected, often delightful items. It adds novelty without changing the mission.
DPC can do a version of this without bloating operations:
- seasonal health weeks: school physicals, sports check-ins, travel prep
- limited-time clinics: vaccine day, skin check day, menopause Q&A night
- partner pop-ins: PT evals, dietitian office hours, behavioral health consult blocks
- prevention challenges: blood pressure month, sleep reset, “walk 10 minutes daily”
The goal isn’t gimmicks. The goal is giving members little moments of “this is why I’m here.”
Create simple rituals and shared language
Aldi has iconic quirks (the cart quarter, the aisle of shame). DPC can build its own identity signals—subtle, not cringe.
Examples:
- “Text us anytime.” (and mean it)
- “Price first.” (before the lab, before the procedure)
- “No surprise bills.” (and reinforce it regularly)
- “We’re direct.” (simple explanations, simple next steps)
These phrases become memorable when they’re backed by consistent behavior.
A community doesn’t require a forum
You don’t need a giant social group to build loyalty. In health care, community can be lighter:
- member newsletters with practical wins
- short, clear explanations of pricing and savings
- “how to use your membership well” tips
- small events that feel human (not corporate)
The real community is often one sentence:
“My doctor actually knows me.”
That is what people talk about.
Make it easy to refer (fans recruit fans)
Aldi fans bring friends. DPC members do too—when it’s simple.
Make referral friction low:
- a one-page “how DPC works” explainer
- a clear pricing page
- a “try it for 30 days” option (if appropriate)
- a friendly script members can use:
- “It’s like Costco for primary care—simple monthly fee, no surprise bills.”
People love sharing something that makes them feel smart.
The takeaway
Aldi wins with a flywheel:
efficiency → low prices → loyalty → community → growth
DPC has its own version:
simplicity → access → trust → stories → growth
If direct care wants to spread, it doesn’t need to outspend big systems. It needs to be so consistently valuable that patients naturally become advocates.
And that starts with delivering the kind of experience people can describe in one breath:
“It’s just… easier.”

Part 2: The Aldi Operating System — Fewer Choices, Lower Costs, Better Experience
The entire store is designed like an engineer got to build a grocery chain from scratch with one goal: remove waste. Not just waste in theory, but waste in time, steps, labor, and complexity.
And that’s where DPC has a huge opportunity—because the biggest cost in American health care isn’t a pill or a lab test.
It’s the administrative machine built around billing, coding, contracting, and arguing.
Fewer choices is a superpower
Aldi limits selection on purpose. Fewer items means:
- less inventory complexity
- simpler supplier relationships
- faster stocking
- fewer moving parts
- lower overhead
The customer doesn’t get 40 kinds of ketchup. They get one or two, and they move on with their life.
Direct care can do the same thing, and many successful practices already do—whether they call it that or not.
Not by offering “less care,” but by offering a clean, tight bundle that covers most real-world needs:
- access (same/next day)
- continuity (a relationship with a clinician who knows you)
- simple communication (text / portal / async)
- transparent pricing
- wholesale meds and labs
- straightforward referrals when needed
When you define the bundle well, you reduce chaos for patients and for staff. And you remove the kind of ambiguity that creates frustration (“Is this covered?” “What will this cost?” “Why did I get this bill?”).
Design for speed (and the patient will feel it)
Aldi famously leaves products in their shipping boxes. That’s not laziness. It’s speed. The goal is to reduce time-to-shelf and minimize labor.
Health care has a thousand “little boxes” too:
- repeated forms
- repeated histories
- repeated logins
- repeated phone calls
- repeated insurance verification
- repeated “we’ll call you back” loops
A DPC clinic doesn’t need to copy retail gimmicks. But it can steal the principle:
everything should be designed for fewer steps.
Examples that patients actually notice:
- “Book online in 30 seconds.”
- “Text us; we answer fast.”
- “Here’s the price before you decide.”
- “Your labs cost $X; if that changes, we tell you first.”
- “We’ll coordinate the referral, not just hand you a phone number.”
This is where experience is born. Not from slogans.
Transparency isn’t marketing—it’s infrastructure
Aldi’s prices are the point. DPC’s pricing should be the point too.
Transparency is not a brochure claim. It’s a system:
- posted fees (or a clear “included vs not included”)
- predictable processes
- consistent language
- no “gotchas”
- easy ways to pay and understand
When transparency is baked into operations, it becomes emotionally calming. People relax when they can predict what happens next.
A caution: don’t turn “efficiency” into “sloppiness”
Aldi sometimes gets messy. Health care can’t. The goal isn’t bare minimum; it’s no waste.
DPC should aim for “quiet excellence”:
- fast response, but accurate
- simple workflow, but thorough
- fewer steps, but safer
- clear boundaries, but warm delivery
Efficiency isn’t cutting corners. Efficiency is removing nonsense so clinicians can do more of what matters.
The DPC version of “limited assortment”
If a practice wants to scale without breaking, it should be able to answer:
- What do we do exceptionally well?
- What do we not do?
- What’s our default workflow for common problems?
- How do we handle after-hours expectations?
- What’s our “this is included” list and our “this is extra” list?
- How do we keep access reliable as we grow?
When those answers are clean, the clinic becomes easier to operate—and easier to recommend.
The takeaway
Aldi proves that the best consumer experience isn’t always the fanciest.
It’s the one designed to be simple, predictable, and efficient.
Direct care’s advantage is the same: remove the administrative sludge, restore clarity, and make the experience feel normal again.
Next up (Part 3): how Aldi turns customers into a community—and how DPC can build a “cult of clarity” without being weird about it.

Part 1: The Aldi Trade — Why People Tolerate Friction When the Value Is Obvious
Aldi is a weird little miracle.
People wake up early, stand in line in the cold, bring a quarter to unlock a shopping cart, accept that there are no free bags, and move through a store that feels intentionally bare-bones. And then they do it again. And again. And then they post about it online like they’ve joined a club.
That’s not an accident. Aldi is a masterclass in a simple idea that health care keeps forgetting:
Consumers will tolerate friction if the payoff is real, consistent, and easy to explain.
The promise is brutally clear
Aldi doesn’t lead with “reimagining grocery.” It leads with saving money. Everything about the experience points back to that promise. The brand isn’t trying to be loved for its ambiance; it’s trying to be trusted for its value.
Direct Primary Care (DPC) works the same way when it works best.
Patients don’t join because they want a “new model.” They join because the promise feels concrete:
- “I can be seen quickly.”
- “I can text my doctor.”
- “I won’t get surprise bills.”
- “Prices are transparent.”
- “This is simpler.”
When DPC tries to be everything to everyone, it stops being memorable. And the moment the promise gets fuzzy, the trade stops feeling worth it.
The trade: small hassle, huge payoff
Aldi’s cart quarter isn’t a bug. It’s a signal: “We run lean, and you benefit from it.” The friction is small, predictable, and shared by everyone. In exchange, the customer gets what they came for: lower prices.
DPC can embrace the same principle:
- Maybe you don’t have a massive call center.
- Maybe scheduling is online-first.
- Maybe there’s a clear scope to what’s included.
- Maybe you don’t do insurance paperwork.
Those can all be acceptable “frictions”—if the patient experiences the payoff immediately:
- Same-day or next-day access
- A doctor who actually responds
- A bill that isn’t a mystery
- Meds/labs that cost what they “should” cost
- No coding games, no middlemen, no runaround
The key isn’t eliminating friction. The key is making the trade feel fair.
Predictability beats perfection
Aldi isn’t perfect. Stores can look messy. Sometimes the shelves are half empty. Yet people keep coming because the core value proposition is reliable.
In health care, patients don’t necessarily expect luxury. They expect:
- clarity
- speed
- fairness
- consistency
If your practice can deliver those, patients will forgive minor inconveniences. But if you deliver convenience without trust—or friendliness without clarity—you’ll lose them the moment they hit a surprise fee, a long wait, or a confusing policy.
A DPC “Aldi test”
Here’s a quick gut-check for any DPC clinic (or any DPC message):
- Can a patient explain your promise in one sentence?
- Do your “rules” feel like they exist to help the patient—or to protect the clinic?
- Does the patient feel the payoff in the first week?
- Do you make the trade explicit (simple, honest), or do you hide it in fine print?
When you make the trade clear, you build confidence. When you hide it, you create suspicion.
The takeaway
Aldi proves something important: people don’t mind “different” if it’s better.
They’ll accept constraints. They’ll even embrace quirks.
But only when those quirks are clearly in service of value.
Direct care doesn’t need to win by being fancy. It wins by being honest, simple, and dependable—and by making the trade so obvious that patients feel smart for choosing it.
Next up (Part 2): the “operating system” behind this—how fewer choices and ruthless simplicity create a better consumer experience and a healthier business.

Why Healthcare Needs Markets — and Why Direct Care Is Actually Working
Two recent essays from Sensible Medicine ask an uncomfortable but important question: why do so many healthcare commentators — including physicians — shy away from market-based thinking?
The hesitation is understandable. Health care is emotional. It involves vulnerability, fear, and moral obligation. When costs rise and access feels fragile, “Medicare for All” sounds like an obvious fix: take something that already exists and simply expand it to everyone. What could go wrong?
Plenty, unfortunately.
Medicare itself isn’t a market. It’s a price-setting system layered with billing rules, coding requirements, compliance audits, contractors, and administrative overhead. Expanding it doesn’t eliminate those problems — it scales them. Medicare for All still requires claims processing, documentation, private administrators, and regulatory enforcement. It doesn’t remove red tape; it standardizes it.
Most importantly, it lacks the feedback mechanisms that markets rely on to improve value, efficiency, and affordability. When prices are divorced from choice, and consumers are insulated from cost signals, systems get expensive fast — even when intentions are good.
This is where direct care matters.
Direct primary care doesn’t claim to solve every healthcare problem. It won’t replace hospitals, emergency care, or catastrophic coverage. But it does something no other model consistently achieves: it makes frequent, everyday care so affordable and accessible that it often doesn’t need insurance at all.
Unlimited visits. No copays. Free telemedicine. Simple procedures included. Transparent pricing. Patients can seek care early and often — when problems are smaller, cheaper, and easier to treat.
That alone hits what many policymakers struggle to define: more care, more often, easier access, and lower cost — simultaneously.
Then there’s the quiet disruption most people miss. By stepping outside traditional insurance billing, direct care clinics routinely offer medications and labs at wholesale prices — often 70–95% less than retail or insurance-based rates. That’s not a theoretical reform. It’s happening now, in real clinics, for real patients.
If we’re serious about fixing healthcare costs, the goal shouldn’t be to insure everything. It should be to make most healthcare too inexpensive to insure in the first place.
Markets aren’t heartless. When designed around patients instead of paperwork, they can be deeply humane. Direct care is proof that when transparency, choice, and accountability return, healthcare gets simpler — and better.