cover image

AAFP's CEO Floated a $75,000 Tax Credit. His Bigger Idea Was Taking Primary Care Out of Insurance.

Every reform panel in American medicine eventually reaches the same polite dead end. Someone asks who will pay for the plan, everyone nods, and the conversation goes back to adjusting the fee schedule by a decimal point.

On Nov. 12, at an open meeting of the National Academies' Standing Committee on Primary Care, somebody walked past that dead end. R. Shawn Martin, CEO and executive vice president of the American Academy of Family Physicians, was asked about the committee's big proposal, a primary care common fund. Then he said this, according to Medical Economics:

"I don't know that primary care needs to sit inside an insurance structure in the traditional way that we've talked about here today, and I think for us to be really innovative, we've got to get really comfortable with thinking about primary care not sitting inside what we would call a legacy insurance structure. And I don't know if the country is ready for that, but I think it's a conversation that needs to be had."

Read it twice. That is the head of the largest family medicine organization in the country, at the National Academies, saying the arrangement we were all trained inside may be the problem.

He wasn't done. He said there is "an enormous amount of financial intermediaries that are intercepting money in the healthcare system." He called cost sharing "both an economic but also a behavioral disincentive to primary care." And on the paperwork: "All the checklists on quality measures, all the utilization management stuff, like, a lot of that stuff just needs to go away."

Intermediaries skimming the money. Copays scaring patients off. Checklists eating the visit. If you have practiced inside the system for any length of time, you could have written that list on a napkin. Plenty of us did, and then we left.

The conversation he says needs to be had has been running in exam rooms for more than a decade. Direct primary care is primary care outside the legacy insurance structure. The patient pays the practice a flat monthly fee. There is no claim, no copay at the door, no prior authorization to see your own doctor. The money goes from the person getting care to the person giving it, and the intermediaries Martin described have nothing to intercept. His own academy's policy on direct primary care says those periodic fees "serve to replace the traditional system of third party insurance coverage for primary care services."

Martin later clarified that people should still have health insurance. Good. So do we. Insurance is a fine tool for the hospital stay, the cancer, the crushed ankle. It is a terrible tool for a sore throat, a blood pressure check, or a text to your doctor at 9 p.m. Matthew Rae of KFF made the coverage point on the same panel: about 14 million people are projected to lose insurance by 2034, and people who lose coverage are "about 4 times less likely to have a usual source of care." That is exactly why the usual source of care shouldn't depend on the insurance card in the first place.

The common fund is where the paths split. The National Academies' version pools money from public and private payers and pays practices a standardized rate, with no cost sharing for patients. Zach Gaumer of the Bipartisan Policy Center asked the right questions right away: paid how, under the old fee schedule or a new bundle, and paid by whom. "I think you need to figure out who's going to pay for this," he said. A fund that sets one rate for every practice is still a payer standing between the doctor and the patient. It is a kinder, simpler payer, maybe, but every central rate eventually becomes a fee schedule, and every fee schedule eventually grows its own checklists.

Then there is the $75,000. Asked for one achievable policy, Martin proposed "something like a $75,000 above-the-line tax credit for 5 to 10 years for people that go into community-based primary care." He thinks it would be "ground-shaking." He may be right, and I'd love to see it. But a tax credit fixes the recruiting pitch, not the job. Bring a young doctor into a 20-visit-a-day schedule with an inbox full of denials, and the credit becomes a retention bonus for burnout.

The job itself is the fix. Smaller panels. Longer visits. Prices patients can see before they walk in. Doctors who answer to the patient instead of the payer. That model exists, it runs in practices across the country, and it doesn't need a waiver or an act of Congress to open on Monday.

So here is the offer back to Martin and the academy. The country may be readier than you think. Thousands of patients already pay for primary care the way they pay for a phone plan, and keep insurance for the catastrophes. Come visit a direct primary care practice. Sit in the 8-by-8 room he talked about, the one where care actually happens. Watch what a visit looks like when nobody is billing for it.

Big ideas make people uncomfortable, he said. This one has been comfortable for its patients for years.

Get the next essay in your inbox: directcare.org/newsletter

Back To Blog
©2026, The Direct Care Foundation.℠ All rights reserved. The Direct Care Foundation℠ is the Trade Name of Alternatives, Inc., a 501(c)3 Alabama non-profit corporation.